Some while back, I decided to decorate my home office with a “wall of heroes” - photo portraits of people I find inspirational. Gloria Steinem is on it, along with Karl Marx, Eugene Victor Debs, Frederick Douglas, John Dewey, Nadine Gordimer, Billie Holiday…
“Splitting” sounds accurate - a concept I am unfamiliar with. I have referred to what today’s young (and not so young) radicals do as “flattening”. They first flatten a long, rich life in time, as if occurred all in one instant, equal-weighted, without growth or development. Then they flatten the pixels, colors to grays, then grays to blunt black-and-white, without subtlety or nuance. Then they judge the result “bad” if they find One Bad Thing.
What human life could possibly survive such reductive treatment? And what moral lessons, what life-enhancing ideas, could possibly be derived from it?
What is inspiring about the heroes on my wall is that they were humans, fallible creatures who struggled, made mistakes, but accomplished some things. Heroes, not angels. Angels are imaginary things. Impossible. One may imagine, if it one finds such things pleasing, how many can dance on a pin, or fit in a clown car. But it won’t do to judge human lives by them.
As a Gloria hater- thank you for this piece! Nuance is important. To write off her work with the CIA off as a blip on her past would be a disingenuous take and a disservice to radical and intersectional feminism. Especially since (to my knowledge, do correct me if I’m wrong) she never outwardly condoned that past decision. On the other hand, to write off Gloria Steinem’s entire legacy due to her work with the cia would be a disservice to the history and evolution of feminism. I’m no Steinem fan. I I’m very critical of both her and her “brand” of feminism. That said I’ve been doing a lot of work lately promoting reproductive rights and legislation- work that might not be possible without Gloria’s. A complicated figure!
It looks like the criticisms (except the conspiracy theory that she ghostwrote for Black women and turned them against Black men) are valid and that they present an unacceptable “second truth” about her to the “first truth” about her expressed in posts uncritically celebrating her. I think the people who are criticizing her are mostly using her participation in CIA-funded, anticommunist propaganda events as a “teachable moment” to illustrate how insidious and destructive CIA propaganda efforts were more generally. It’s not just the funding that is the issue, but the activity she engaged in itself that is an issue. And I think that, given the death tolls from CIA activity and American imperialism in Latin America motivated by anticommunist ideology, people are justified in not celebrating her. She was at one point of her life a kind of lady, liberal Charlie Kirk. When young conservative men show up at college campuses asking to “debate DEI”, we shouldn’t infantilize them. And we should definitely see parallels between her Cold War era activities and the “debate me” bros of today.
Meant to restack that what particularly landed for me was the amazing growth and love of her grandmother- the same as my 98 year old mother who afforded engagement and experience has changed so much over her lifetime and I am so honored to be her daughter.
I appreciated your specific description of splitting. I posted last night about what you might call splitting in my own experience. How can we admire people that we do not always agree with. Through out all of life people evolve and change, change their views and we can choose to hear what speaks to us .
Curious where are your sources for any of this? I'd love to learn more and confirm what you're saying here, and that's hard without knowing where any of this info came from. Is there a reason you don't cite any sources? Seems odd if you're trying to "debunk" a claim - sources would only lend more credit to your argument.
Amazing writing. I think there is also something that predates the internet: a mindset to criticise before we praise, to find fault with other intellectual ideas almost as sport.
Before reading this, I didn't know much beyond Gloria Steinem's name. I enjoyed learning about what she has done and how you were able to debunk these negative labels she's been given in her passing. A lot of what I've read lately seems to deal in absolutes, so your holding space for nuance is refreshing (:
Some while back, I decided to decorate my home office with a “wall of heroes” - photo portraits of people I find inspirational. Gloria Steinem is on it, along with Karl Marx, Eugene Victor Debs, Frederick Douglas, John Dewey, Nadine Gordimer, Billie Holiday…
“Splitting” sounds accurate - a concept I am unfamiliar with. I have referred to what today’s young (and not so young) radicals do as “flattening”. They first flatten a long, rich life in time, as if occurred all in one instant, equal-weighted, without growth or development. Then they flatten the pixels, colors to grays, then grays to blunt black-and-white, without subtlety or nuance. Then they judge the result “bad” if they find One Bad Thing.
What human life could possibly survive such reductive treatment? And what moral lessons, what life-enhancing ideas, could possibly be derived from it?
What is inspiring about the heroes on my wall is that they were humans, fallible creatures who struggled, made mistakes, but accomplished some things. Heroes, not angels. Angels are imaginary things. Impossible. One may imagine, if it one finds such things pleasing, how many can dance on a pin, or fit in a clown car. But it won’t do to judge human lives by them.
She was a zionist and genocide supporter, completer fraud
As a Gloria hater- thank you for this piece! Nuance is important. To write off her work with the CIA off as a blip on her past would be a disingenuous take and a disservice to radical and intersectional feminism. Especially since (to my knowledge, do correct me if I’m wrong) she never outwardly condoned that past decision. On the other hand, to write off Gloria Steinem’s entire legacy due to her work with the cia would be a disservice to the history and evolution of feminism. I’m no Steinem fan. I I’m very critical of both her and her “brand” of feminism. That said I’ve been doing a lot of work lately promoting reproductive rights and legislation- work that might not be possible without Gloria’s. A complicated figure!
Thank You.
It looks like the criticisms (except the conspiracy theory that she ghostwrote for Black women and turned them against Black men) are valid and that they present an unacceptable “second truth” about her to the “first truth” about her expressed in posts uncritically celebrating her. I think the people who are criticizing her are mostly using her participation in CIA-funded, anticommunist propaganda events as a “teachable moment” to illustrate how insidious and destructive CIA propaganda efforts were more generally. It’s not just the funding that is the issue, but the activity she engaged in itself that is an issue. And I think that, given the death tolls from CIA activity and American imperialism in Latin America motivated by anticommunist ideology, people are justified in not celebrating her. She was at one point of her life a kind of lady, liberal Charlie Kirk. When young conservative men show up at college campuses asking to “debate DEI”, we shouldn’t infantilize them. And we should definitely see parallels between her Cold War era activities and the “debate me” bros of today.
For sure. People change.
Meant to restack that what particularly landed for me was the amazing growth and love of her grandmother- the same as my 98 year old mother who afforded engagement and experience has changed so much over her lifetime and I am so honored to be her daughter.
I appreciated your specific description of splitting. I posted last night about what you might call splitting in my own experience. How can we admire people that we do not always agree with. Through out all of life people evolve and change, change their views and we can choose to hear what speaks to us .
Curious where are your sources for any of this? I'd love to learn more and confirm what you're saying here, and that's hard without knowing where any of this info came from. Is there a reason you don't cite any sources? Seems odd if you're trying to "debunk" a claim - sources would only lend more credit to your argument.
I really appreciate this piece for its clarity and compassion AND for being able to hear it in the author’s voice.
you've been quiet. Are you okay?
Has anybody heard from Alisa lately? I see likes and restacks but I am bothered.
Amazing writing. I think there is also something that predates the internet: a mindset to criticise before we praise, to find fault with other intellectual ideas almost as sport.
Before reading this, I didn't know much beyond Gloria Steinem's name. I enjoyed learning about what she has done and how you were able to debunk these negative labels she's been given in her passing. A lot of what I've read lately seems to deal in absolutes, so your holding space for nuance is refreshing (:
I hope you are feeling better, thinking of you. From Pa to Spain giving healing energy.💖
You are a helluva writer and captured the whole thing. Thank you